Datacat

Insights

2026-11-15 · 6 min

Contractor quotes you can compare like for like

Three contractor quotes can price different jobs. Send one written scope with photos, ask for itemised lines, then compare cost, exclusions and timing.

Picture an operator that needs a leaking roof section repaired at one of its sites and asks three contractors to quote. The first quote is a single figure. The second is cheaper but excludes access equipment and disposal. The third is the most expensive and includes replacing the gutters nobody asked for. The facilities lead picks the cheapest number, and the variation for the lift hire arrives once the job is under way.

Nobody did anything wrong on paper. Each contractor priced the job they imagined, because nobody gave them the same job to price.

Three quotes, three different jobs

Quotes stop being comparable long before anyone opens them. Causes can include:

  • The scope lives in a phone call. Each contractor hears a slightly different description, depending on who answered and what they asked.
  • Each visit sees something different. One contractor meets the site manager on the roof; another inspects from the car park.
  • The format is the contractor’s, not yours. A lump sum, a page of line items and a scope letter can’t be lined up against each other.
  • Exclusions sit in the fine print. Access, disposal, after-hours work and make-good are where a low price quietly becomes a high one.

A handful of your own recent quotes will show which ones apply.

Write the scope before you ask for a price

Put the request in writing, once, and send the same version to everyone. A useful scope covers:

  • What is wrong, with photos and where it is on the site.
  • What a finished job looks like, including any standard or finish you expect.
  • Access conditions, trading hours and any induction the site requires.
  • What is out of scope, so nobody prices extras you don’t want.

If a contractor needs to inspect before pricing, add what they found to the shared scope and send the update to every contractor still quoting. One visit should not give one contractor information the others never saw.

Ask every contractor to price the same lines

Give contractors a short price template instead of taking whatever arrives: labour, materials, access equipment, disposal, call-out and any allowances, each on its own line. Add a line for anything excluded and ask for an attendance date and expected duration.

Itemised quotes take a contractor a little longer to write and save you guessing at what each price covers. They also give you real figures for the next similar job, which is where jobs that keep the margin you quoted picks up the costing side.

Compare the whole job, not the bottom line

Lay the quotes out line by line and fill the gaps before deciding. Where one contractor left out access equipment, add a realistic figure to their total so the comparison is fair. Then weigh what the price doesn’t show: how soon they can attend, how long the work holds them on site and how that contractor has performed on your recent jobs.

Record why the winning quote won. When the same repair comes up at another site, the next person starts from a decision with reasons, not just a name and a number. Contractor panel reviews from job records covers how that job history adds up.

Put your last five quoted repairs side by side

Pull the last five repairs you sent out for quotes. For each one, check whether every contractor received the same written scope, whether the quotes could be compared line by line, and whether the final invoice matched the quote you chose.

If several of the variations trace back to something the scope never said, the fix starts with the request, not the contractor.

Repairs that start from the job record in OpsChase

OpsChase is one AI-powered platform for multi-site operators, with scheduling, jobs, assets and planned maintenance, and compliance available. The repair starts as a job logged by the site, with photos, notes and asset details in one place, so the scope you write for pricing starts from the record your team already reviewed. Operations set the trade and priority, the job goes to your own team or one of your regular contractors, and the job stays on the record with photos and sign-off until the work is done. Datacat’s OpsChase overview shows how it fits multi-site maintenance.

Datacat can set up scope templates, price lines and approval steps as part of a regular contractor and work order system shaped around your sites. See work we have delivered, or send us two quotes you struggled to compare and we’ll show where they priced different jobs. Remove names, prices you can’t share and other sensitive details first.